Skip to content
nate d sanders auctions logo
  • AuctionExpand
    • Current Auction
    • Instructions
  • Register
  • ConsignExpand
    • Consign With Us
    • Noteable Estates & Testimonials
  • Prices Realized
  • Blog
  • In The News
  • My Account
  • Contact
Facebook X YouTube Linkedin
nate d sanders auctions logo
Home » Uncategorized
Uncategorized

Sell or Auction Your Arnold Rothstein Autograph for up to Over $3,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions

ByNate D Sanders February 3, 2023December 4, 2023

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

FREE ESTIMATE. To buy, auction, sell or consign your Arnold Rothstein autograph that is for sale, please email your description and photos to [email protected] of Nate D. Sanders Auctions (http://www.NateDSanders.com).

Free Appraisal, Auction or Sell Your Arnold Rothstein Autograph

Rothstein in 1919 {{PD-US}}

Below is a recent realized price for an autograph from American crime boss Arnold Rothstein. We at Nate D. Sanders Auctions can obtain up to this amount or more for you:

Arnold Rothstein Autograph. Sold for Over $3,000.

The following are some related items we have sold:

Astonishing John Dillinger Autograph Letter Signed Regarding Letter — ”…Sweetheart if I had known two months ago that you would ever care enough about me to marry me I would have gotten a job…” — With JSA COA

Emotional and scarce John Dillinger autograph letter signed, written in October 1933, less than two weeks before he escaped from prison in Lima, Ohio. He writes to Mary Longnaker, his girlfriend and the sister of his recently killed buddy Jim Jenkins. The robbers met while they were both incarcerated at the Michigan City penitentiary in Indiana in 1929, along with future members of their bank-robbing gang Harry Pierpont and Homer Van Meter. Dillinger and Longnaker met and started their courtship while Dillinger was released from prison in May of 1933. Five months later, the FBI’s first official “Public Enemy #1” writes to her from prison following another arrest. He dates the letter 1 October 1933, and the postmarked envelope from Lima is stamped 2 October 1933. The touching text reads in full: “Dearest Mary, I just read in the paper of Jimmys death and I know you must be heartbroken. I feel for you dear for I know how much you cared for each other, and I can understand your grief because Jimmy was the only real friend and pal I had outside of my family and I loved him like a brother. Honey this old world has delt [sic] you some heavy blows. I wish I were free so I could take you away and make you happy but the least I can expect is ten years. Sweetheart if I had known two months ago that you would ever care enough about me to marry me I would have gotten a job somehow for I could enjoy working for a girl like you and having a home. Do you think I have enjoyed myself always on the go, no place I could call home. I expect you were surprised to hear I was sent to Lima weren’t you? I wish you would send me the pictures we had taken at the worlds fair. I will always keep them in remembrance of you. Darling I won’t write you any more, I want you to forget me for ten years or more is to long for any girl to wait, and as sweet as you are you will find the right man someday to make you happy. Dear I am heartbroken too about Jimmy for he was a wonderful fellow. Goodbye and the best of luck to you always. Love from Johnnie.” Less than two weeks later, on 12 October, Dillinger’s buddies broke him out of prison, and though he sought out Mary, she refused him due to his status as a fugitive. In less than a year, he’d be shot dead by federal police in a sting involving his new girlfriend. Letter runs 2pp. and measures 7.5″ x 9.75″. Toning and separation at fold lines. Very good condition. With JSA COA. Exceptionally scarce John Dillinger autograph letter signed; less than ten examples of just his signature are known to exist and this is the only letter we have encountered.  Just as rare as an Al Capone autograph but worth only 1/3 to 1/4 of an Al Capone autograph.  Sold for $17,365.

Arnold Rothstein autograph
Click image to enlarge.

Clyde Barrow Autograph Note Signed — Infamous Gangster Sends a Postcard to His Mother — ”…hello mother – just fine. We are…drunk as hell…” — With JSA COA

Clyde Barrow postcard signed, dated 30 September 1929. Before he became half of the 1930’s crime duo of Bonnie and Clyde, Barrow sends a postcard from Mexico addressed to Mrs. H.B. Barrow in Dallas. He writes in pencil, ”hello mother – just fine. We are in old Mexico. drunk as hell. Will see you in about 3 weeks. Clyde + Grace.” Only 20 years old at this time, Barrow met Bonnie Parker a few months later, and would be dead within five years after a multi-state crime spree that captured the public imagination. A Mexican stamp is affixed to the upper right corner of the 3.25” x 5.5” postcard. Light soiling, else very good. Nicely framed with period photographs of him and Bonnie. Just as scarce as an Al Capone autograph, but only worth 1/7 of an Al Capone autograph. With JSA COA.  Sold for $10,780.

Arnold Rothstein autograph
Click image to enlarge.

John Gotti Lot of Six Autograph Letters Signed from Prison — ”…I’ve been waiting patiently for people to rebut and expose that lying Pricks Book and interview and show the fag that he was…”

Collection of six autograph letters signed by John Gotti, written during the late 1990s when he was serving time in prison for crimes committed as boss of the Gambino crime family. All letters are written inside cards, addressed to his wife’s sister, Marylou DiGiorgio, and usually signed ”Johnny!” All are additionally signed on the return address panel of the envelopes, ”Gotti” along with his prison number. In each card he sends love and well wishes to his extended family. Cards measure 7.125” x 5”. Tears to envelopes, not affecting writing, overall in very good plus condition. Sold for $4,834.

Arnold Rothstein autograph
Click image to enlarge.

John Gotti Lot of Three Autograph Letters Signed from Prison — ”…it took you and the rest of the country almost four years to learn that I was right about [George H.W.] Bush!…I told ya so!…”

Collection of three autograph letters signed by John Gotti, written during the 1990s when he was serving time in prison for crimes committed as boss of the Gambino crime family. All letters are written inside cards, addressed to his wife’s sister, Marylou DiGiorgio, and usually signed ”Johnny!” All are additionally signed on the return address panel of the envelopes, ”Gotti” along with his prison number. . Cards vary in size, measuring approximately 7” x 4”. Tears to envelopes, only one affecting the top of Gotti’s signature, overall in very good plus condition. Sold for $3,543.

Arnold Rothstein autograph
Click image to enlarge.

John Gotti Lot of Three Autograph Letters Signed from Prison — ”…my daughter Vicki sent me the novel ‘The NoteBook’…if you get a chance read it – much like ‘Bridges of Madison County’…”

Collection of three autograph letters signed by John Gotti, written in 1993 and 1995 when he was serving time in prison for crimes committed as boss of the Gambino crime family. All letters are written inside cards, addressed to his wife’s sister, Marylou DiGiorgio, and usually signed ”Johnny!” All are additionally signed on the return address panel of the envelopes, ”Gotti” along with his prison number. Cards measure 7.125” x 5”. Tears to envelopes, only one affecting the very top of Gotti’s signature, overall in very good plus condition. Sold for $2,926.

Arnold Rothstein autograph
Click image to enlarge.

John Gotti Lot of Three Autograph Letters Signed from Prison Including One After His Prison Beating — ”…to my dental situation, still no work done – also no word on the motion for a new trial…”

Lot of three autograph letters signed by John Gotti, written from 1996-2000 when he was serving time in prison for crimes committed as boss of the Gambino crime family. All letters are written inside cards, addressed to his wife’s sister, Marylou DiGiorgio, and usually signed ”Johnny!” All are additionally signed on the return address panel of the envelopes, ”Gotti” along with his prison number. Cards measure approximately 7.125” x 5”. Tears to envelopes, only one slightly affecting the top of Gotti’s signature, overall in very good plus condition. Sold for $2,660.

Arnold Rothstein autograph
Click image to enlarge.

1887 Document Signed by Ringleaders in the Lincoln Country War — Including James Dolan, Justice of the Peace John Wilson, Sheriff Peppin & Regulator Yginio Salazar

Fantastic and rare legal document signed by dozens of key officials in Lincoln County, New Mexico, home of the 1878 Lincoln County War shootouts that catapulted Billy the Kid to fame. During the five short months of February-July 1878, the Lincoln County War would pit two factions of outlaws against each other for control of economic power in Lincoln County, and not end until federal forces intervened at the Battle of Lincoln. This 1887 document is signed by 24 Lincoln County notables who are petitioning the Board of County Commissioners to limit the width of a major road leading to the Court House. Document dated 15 July 1887 is signed by: James Dolan (leader of the Murphy/Dolan faction), Justice of the Peace John Wilson (who deputized the outlaw Regulators gang), George Peppin (the corrupt Sheriff who helped Murphy/Dolan’s thugs) and Yginio Salazar (one of Billy the Kid’s Regulators). Document is also signed by Sheriff Jason Brent, New Mexican Governor George Curry, Octaviano Salas (a Coroner’s Juror for Alex McSween’s murder), John Wheeler (who rode with Billy the Kid), cattleman George Barber, William Rosenthal (who sued John Chisum), George Sena (Pat Garrett’s Deputy Sheriff), Sheriff Saturnino Baca, Antonio Salazar (the local tax collector) and John Thornton (whose family defended Dolan and Chisum). Document runs two pages (front and verso) with all signatures appearing on the second page, and includes an integral leaf with docketing approving the petition. Measures 7.75″ x 9.75″. A spectacular document displaying the signatures of men who sought to break the untamed West. Sold for $2,237.

Click image to enlarge.

Exceptionally Rare Carte de Visite of the Jesse James and Younger Gang, Circa 1876 — Depicting 6 Outlaws Involved in the Famed Northfield, Minnesota Botched Bank Raid

Very scarce 1876 CDV of 6 members of Jesse James’ infamous James and Younger Gang, as well as a bank teller victim, after their failed attempt to rob the First National Bank in Northfield, Minnesota. CDV contains images of James-Younger gang members: Bob Younger, Jim Younger and Cole Younger, as well as Charlie Pitts, Bill Chadwell, Clell Millet and murdered bank teller Joseph Haywood. The day of the failed robbery, 7 September 1876, marked the beginning of the end for the infamous James-Younger gang as its members were captured or killed, save for the James’ brothers, who just barely escaped. In addition to Miller and Stiles dead, every gang member was wounded, including Cole who was shot in his left hip, Frank James in his right leg and Jesse James, the last to be shot, getting a bullet in the thigh as the gang escaped. The Youngers surrendered, and pleaded guilty to murder in order to avoid execution. CDV photographer’s backmark reads: “Den Chamberlain Mitchell’s Block, NO.13, 2ND ST., Winona, – Minn.” CDV measures 2.5″ x 4″. Some fading, else near fine. Sold for $1,954.

Exceptionally Rare Carte de Visite of the Jesse James and Younger Gang. Click to enlarge.

John Gotti Lot of Three Autograph Letters Signed from Prison — “…my daughter Vicki sent me the novel ‘The NoteBook’…if you get a chance read it – much like ‘Bridges of Madison County’…”

Collection of three autograph letters signed by John Gotti, written in 1993 and 1995 when he was serving time in prison for crimes committed as boss of the Gambino crime family. All letters are written inside cards, addressed to his wife’s sister, Marylou DiGiorgio, and usually signed “Johnny!” All are additionally signed on the return address panel of the envelopes, “Gotti” along with his prison number.

In one letter, postmarked 13 October 1995, Gotti writes in part, “…I just finished a two day visit with Johnny [likely Johnny DiGiorgio, who served prison time for racketeering, loan-sharking and kidnapping after turning state’s witness]…Johnny also told me about his business plans – I think he’s headed in the right direction…some one sent me a copy of the book ‘Ageless Body, Timeless Mind.’ So I finally got to read it – amazing! Also my daughter Vicki sent me the novel ‘The NoteBook,’ by Nicholas Sparks – if you get a chance read it – much like ‘Bridges of Madison County’. I’m sure you’ll enjoy it. By the way, Johnny spent an hour telling me your thanksgiving day menu – and that you make everything from scratch, which takes at least two days – My mouth was watering – if it were possible you’d have a good customer in me – I’d even bring the wine!…Give Johnny and the children my love – know that I miss all of you…Love, Johnny!”

In another letter, postmarked 14 July 1993, Gotti writes, “…I received a letter tonight from Johnny – one of the things he writes is that your neighbor and friend – Donna passed away…You know my tennis pics both fell short of the mark!…Funny thing I wrote Johnny a letter asking certain questions – and the very next night I receive his letter asking almost the same things. Take Care, and smile. Love – Johnny!”. In Gotti’s last letter, postmarked 17 November 1995, Gotti wishes the family a “happy and healthy Thanksgiving day!…I’ve been working diligently on the motion for a new trial – which is to be presented by 12/15/95…as for me, I feel great!…Love and miss you – Love Johnny”. Cards measure 7.125″ x 5″. Tears to envelopes, only one affecting the very top of Gotti’s signature, overall in very good plus condition. Sold for $1,076.

Click image to enlarge.

FREE ESTIMATE. To buy, auction, sell or consign your Arnold Rothstein autograph that is for sale, please email your description and photos to [email protected] of Nate D. Sanders Auctions (http://www.NateDSanders.com).

We offer the following services for your Arnold Rothstein autograph:

  • Appraise Arnold Rothstein autograph.
  • Auction Arnold Rothstein autograph.
  • Consign Arnold Rothstein autograph.
  • Estimate Arnold Rothstein autograph.
  • Sell Arnold Rothstein autograph.

Related Posts

  • Sell or Auction Your Takatoku Batman Friction-Powered Plane for up to About $20,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
  • Sell or Auction Your Derasco Batpen Counter Display and Pen for up to About $20,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
  • Sell or Auction Your Bandai Black Batmobile in Original Box for up to Over $17,500 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
Follow the latest on art, autographs, memorabilia, movie memorabilia, space memorabilia & sports memorabilia.

© 2026 Hollywood Memorabilia, Fine Autographs, & Consignments Blog

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

  • Auction
    • Current Auction
    • Instructions
  • Register
  • Consign
    • Consign With Us
    • Noteable Estates & Testimonials
  • Prices Realized
  • Blog
  • In The News
  • My Account
  • Contact
Facebook X Instagram
Search