Skip to content
nate d sanders auctions logo
  • AuctionExpand
    • Current Auction
    • Instructions
  • Register
  • ConsignExpand
    • Consign With Us
    • Noteable Estates & Testimonials
  • Prices Realized
  • Blog
  • In The News
  • My Account
  • Contact
Facebook X YouTube Linkedin
nate d sanders auctions logo
Home » Uncategorized
Uncategorized

Sell or Auction Your 1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back PSA 9 for up to Nearly $6,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions

ByNate D Sanders December 15, 2019August 15, 2021

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

FREE APPRAISAL. To buy, auction, sell or consign your 1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back PSA 9 that is for sale, please email your description and photos to [email protected] of Nate D. Sanders Auctions (http://www.NateDSanders.com).

Sell Your 1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back PSA 9

Allie Pierce Reynolds (February 10, 1917 – December 26, 1994) was drafted by the New York Giants as a halfback out of Oklahoma A&M, now Oklahoma State, but Reynolds chose baseball as he preferred the diamond to the gridiron and saw greater riches in baseball. He signed with the Cleveland Indians in 1939 and spent three seasons in the minors honing his pitching skills. In 1942, after floundering in the minors, Allie considered retirement, but was called up to the Majors after he went 18-7 with a 1.56 ERA, threw 11 shutouts, 193 strikeouts and 21 complete games in his final year with Wilkes-Barre. Reynolds was added to the depleted Cleveland Indians pitching staff in 1943 as manager Lou Boudreau utilized the big, durable right-hander as a reliever between starts. Allie Reynolds pitched 13 seasons in the big with the Indians (1942-1946) and the New York Yankees (1947-1954). Superchief, as he was called due to his American-Indian heritage, won ten or more games in every full season he played in the American League, posting a career high 20 wins in 1952. That same season, Allie led the AL in earned run average (2.06), and shutouts (6) for a second straight year. He also led the AL in strikeouts (151) in his rookie campaign (1943). Allie Reynolds was a six-time MLB All-Star selection and helped the New York Yankees win six World Series titles (1947, 1949-1953). Reynolds compiled a record of 182-107 in 434 games with 137 complete games, 49 saves, 1,423 strikeouts and a career 3.30 ERA.

Here is a 1952 Topps Allie Reynolds 67 Black Back PSA 9 baseball card we sold:

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds # 67 NY Black Back — PSA 9 — Population 1 of 1 — Sold for $6,000.

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back PSA 9
1952 Topps Allie Reynolds # 67 NY Black Back — PSA 9. Click to enlarge.

The following are some additional baseball cards we sold:

1952 Topps Mickey Mantle #311 SGC 80

Sold by us. Worth $80,000+ currently.

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back PSA 9
1952 Topps Mickey Mantle #311 SGC 80. Click to enlarge.

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 NY Black Back PSA 9 — Sold for $6,000.

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 NY Black Back — PSA 9 — Population 1 of 1. Click to enlarge.

1952 Topps — Duke Snider #37 — PSA 9 — Black Back — Population 1 of 2 — Sold for $9,000.

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back PSA 9
1952 Topps — Duke Snider #37 — PSA 9 — Black Back — Population 1 of 2. Click to enlarge.

1952 Topps Willard Marshall #96 PSA 9 Red — Sold for $4,002.

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back PSA 9
1952 Topps Willard Marshall #96 PSA 9 Red. Click to enlarge.

1952 Topps — Eddie Yuhas #386 — PSA 8.5 — Population 1 of 1 — Sold for $3,197.

1952 Topps Eddie Yuhas #386 PSA 8.5. Click to enlarge.

1952 Topps Bob Mahoney PSA 9 — Sold for $1,573.

1952 Topps Bob Mahoney PSA 9. Click to enlarge.

FREE APPRAISAL. To buy, auction, sell or consign your 1952 Topps Allie Reynolds # 67 Black Back PSA 9 that is for sale, please email your description and photos to [email protected] of Nate D. Sanders Auctions (http://www.NateDSanders.com).

Related Posts

  • Sell or Auction Your 1960 Fender Precision Bass Bass Guitar for up to About $25,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
  • Sell or Auction Your 1960 Gibson ES-355 Stereo Electric Guitar for up to Nearly $25,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
  • Sell or Auction Your Beastie Boys Signed Record Album LP for up to Nearly $17,500 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
Follow the latest on art, autographs, memorabilia, movie memorabilia, space memorabilia & sports memorabilia.

© 2026 Hollywood Memorabilia, Fine Autographs, & Consignments Blog

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

  • Auction
    • Current Auction
    • Instructions
  • Register
  • Consign
    • Consign With Us
    • Noteable Estates & Testimonials
  • Prices Realized
  • Blog
  • In The News
  • My Account
  • Contact
Facebook X Instagram
Search