Skip to content
nate d sanders auctions logo
  • AuctionExpand
    • Current Auction
    • Instructions
  • Register
  • ConsignExpand
    • Consign With Us
    • Noteable Estates & Testimonials
  • Prices Realized
  • Blog
  • In The News
  • My Account
  • Contact
Facebook X YouTube Linkedin
nate d sanders auctions logo
Home » Uncategorized
Uncategorized

Sell or Auction Your 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5 for up to Over $45,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions

ByNate D Sanders March 19, 2020February 12, 2021

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

FREE APPRAISAL. To buy, auction, sell or consign your 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5 that is for sale, please email your description and photos to [email protected] of Nate D. Sanders Auctions (http://www.NateDSanders.com).

Sell Your 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5

John Constantine Unitas (May 7, 1933 – September 11, 2002), nicknamed “Johnny U” and “The Golden Arm”, was an American professional football player in the National Football League (NFL). He spent the majority of his career playing for the Baltimore Colts. He was a record-setting quarterback, and the NFL’s most valuable player in 1959, 1964, and 1967.

For 52 years, he held the records for most consecutive games with a touchdown pass (set between 1956 and 1960), until it was broken in 2012 by Drew Brees. Unitas was the prototype of the modern era marquee quarterback, with a strong passing game, media fanfare, and widespread popularity. He has been consistently listed as one of the greatest NFL players of all time.

1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5 sold for nearly $45,000.

1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5

Here are some football items we sold at Nate D. Sanders Auctions:

1955 Topps All-American — Otto Graham #12 — PSA 10 — Population 1 of 1 — Sold for $7,999.

1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5
1955 Topps All-American — Otto Graham #12 — PSA 10 — Population 1 of 1. Click to enlarge.

1959 Topps — Green Bay Packers HOF Paul Hornung #82 — PSA 10 — Population 1 of 1 — Sold for $3,066.

1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5
1959 Topps — Green Bay Packers HOF Paul Hornung #82 — PSA 10. Click to enlarge.

1951 Bowman — Ernie Stautner #96 — PSA 9 — Population 1 of 3 — Rookie Card — Hall of Famer — Sold for $2,094.

1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5
1951 Bowman — Ernie Stautner #96 — PSA 9 — Population 1 of 3. Click to enlarge.

1956 Topps — Frank Gifford #53 — PSA 10 — Population 1 of 3 — Sold for $1,806.

1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5
1956 Topps — Frank Gifford #53 — PSA 10 — Population 1 of 3. Click to enlarge.

Colts 1st Game Ball Signed 1947

Signed 1947 game ball from the Colts’ very first game, played 7 September 1947. Signed by 31 members of the original Colts team, ball features the printed seal of the All-America Football Conference and Commissioner J.H. Ingram. Among signatures are head coach Cecil Isbell, as well as quarterback Ernie Case, offensive guard Augie Lio, defensive end Lamar Davis and backers Andy Dudish, John Vardian and Bill Hillenbrad. The Colts defeated the Brooklyn Dodgers 16-7 in that historic first game in Baltimore. In 1946 Robert Rodenburg purchased the bankrupt Miami Seahawks and moved the franchise to Baltimore for the 1947 season. The new owner launched a contest for fans to name the new team. Contestants submitted a team name, explaining their reasons for the choice in 25 words or less. The winner was Charles Wilbur Evans, one of three contestants who submitted “Colts.” Mr. Evans believed the name celebrated Baltimore’s long, proud history in horse racing and, with five letters, would read easily in newsprint. He won and his prize included an AM/FM radio, season tickets, a U.S. savings bond and the team’s first game ball, personally delivered to his home by new owner Rodenburg. The ball remained in Mr. Evans’ family for almost 60 years and was acquired by us from his grandson. Some fading to signatures in black ink, otherwise good condition. One-of-a-kind piece of Baltimore Colts history. Sold for $9,580.

Colts 1st Game Ball Signed 1947. Click to enlarge.

1968 Baltimore Colts 18k Gold Watch

Baltimore Colts Championship wristwatch from defensive back Ocie Austin. Fine Lucien Picard 18k gold wristwatch presented in recognition of the Baltimore Colts 1968 NFL Championship. The watch face features the Colts logo, NFL logo and proclamation, “Baltimore Colts Champions 1968.” Reverse engraved with Austin’s initials “O.M.A.” and number “37.” Minimal wear, near mint condition. Sold for $3,392.

Click on image to enlarge.

Consign your 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5 at Nate D. Sanders Auctions. Send a description and images of your 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5 to us at [email protected].

Baltimore Colts 1968 Signed Football — With Johnny Unitas & John Mackey — JSA COA

Football signed by 17 of the 1968 Baltimore Colts. Signatures include those of Johnny Unitas, John Mackey, Earl Morrall, Roy Hilton, Jimmy Ward, Jerry Logan, Willie Richardson, Timmy Brown, Tom Matte, Bubba Smith, Ordell Braase, Fred Miller, Mike Curtis, Dan Sullivan, Lou Michaels, Jerry Hill and Lenny Lyles. Super Pro 44 ball measures 11.5″ long. In near fine condition. With JSA COA for all signatures. Sold for $566.

  • 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5
    Click on image to enlarge.
  • 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5
    Click on image to enlarge.

Johnny Unitas 8” x 10” Signed Glossy Photo — ”Johnny Unitas” — Fine — PSA/DNA COA — Sold for $238.

1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5
Johnny Unitas 8” x 10” Signed Glossy Photo. Click to enlarge.
Click to enlarge.

FREE APPRAISAL. To buy, auction, sell or consign your 1957 Topps John Unitas # 138 PSA 8.5 that is for sale, please email your description and photos to [email protected] of Nate D. Sanders Auctions (http://www.NateDSanders.com).

We offer the following services for your 1957 Topps John Unitas # 138 PSA 8.5:

  • Appraise 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5.
  • Auction 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5.
  • Sell 1957 Topps John Unitas #138 PSA 8.5.

Related Posts

  • Sell or Auction Your Tudor Rose Batman Batcopter for up to About $20,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
  • Sell or Auction Your Kenrick Gray Batman in Original Packaging for up to Nearly $12,500 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
  • Sell or Auction Your Tada Batman Robin Rifle in Original Box for up to Nearly $9,000 or More at Nate D. Sanders Auctions
Follow the latest on art, autographs, memorabilia, movie memorabilia, space memorabilia & sports memorabilia.

© 2026 Hollywood Memorabilia, Fine Autographs, & Consignments Blog

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

Consign With Us

Do you have a high-value item that you would like to get the maximum price possible? If so, please call us at (310) 440-2982 or use the form below. A representative of Nate D. Sanders Auctions will contact you concerning your items.

Attach up to 4 pictures in gif, jpg or png format not to exceed 4Mb.

There are two methods to select your images after you clicking “Choose Files”:

While holding the Shift Key down, select the first image and the last image. All images between will be highlighted.

While holding the CTrl Key down, select each image one click at a time. Only the selected images will be chosen. Then click “Open” and the selected files will be included in the form.

You can also email us at [email protected]

  • Auction
    • Current Auction
    • Instructions
  • Register
  • Consign
    • Consign With Us
    • Noteable Estates & Testimonials
  • Prices Realized
  • Blog
  • In The News
  • My Account
  • Contact
Facebook X Instagram
Search